What Color Is White?
Posted January 5th, 2009 by Brian PearceCategories: Uncategorized
For anyone working in the video or graphics industry the question of absolute color is essential. I’m sure we’ve all seen something on one display that looked great, but when shown on another looked terrible, or not at all like the original creation. The same thing happens in video production. In live production it isn’t uncommon to look at the projection screens and realize that the image doesn’t match the reality of the scene on stage. For anyone wondering if there isn’t any sort of standardization to the question of color, there is. The television broadcast industry and motion picture industry tackled these questions decades ago. Unfortunately in the quest for a manufacturer to capture your eye while shopping for a new television or projector, for many displays the standards are completely ignored.
Let’s start with what the broadcast standard actually is. When the color television system was standardized in the United States, the color of white was chosen to be 6500 Kelvin on the 1931 CIE chart. For those of you who have no idea what that chart is, give it a quick Google search and you’ll get a pretty picture of grids and colors. Peruse the Wikipedia explanations and you’ll learn some fun terms like “black body curve” and such. The quick and dirty explanation is that if an “ideal metal” is heated to a specific temperature measured in Kelvin, there is a specific color of light given off that can be used as a standard. Since there are a range of colors that humans perceive as white, other temperatures can be used as standards. In Japan and also in many computer monitors 9300 Kelvin is the standard for white. This is much closer to the color blue than 6500K so if two monitors were side by side at these color temperatures, they’d look very different even if displaying the same image. In the motion picture industry, 5600 Kelvin is the standard which is slightly redder or warmer looking than 6500K. The point is not necessarily that there are different definitions of white, but that the proper standard should be selected for your application, and that all displays throughout the entire production chain are calibrated the same so that what you see on one is the same as all the others.
Here is a quick review on color and the perception of color. Remember in elementary school how we learned that colors can be mixed together to create other colors? When Red, Green, and Blue mix together for any known display technology, they will produce the color white. This is called an additive color system. In order to produce a specific color temperature, the relative amounts of red, green, and blue are changed in order to move the result along the continuum between the reddish side of white and the bluish side of white.
Let’s look at a practical example of where calibration would be beneficial. Consider a camera production scenario. There is a video assist monitor on the camera, shot monitor in the control room, preview and program monitors, shading monitor, capture and editing monitors, and let’s say some projectors in a live room for IMAG (Image Magnification). Which of these monitors do you think is telling the truth of what the image looks like and what if the final product on the projectors doesn’t look like what you see on stage in the room? That’s a difficult decision and one you should never have to make. With proper calibration, all monitors from the video assist monitor to the projector could be adjusted to the video standard of 6500K within the physical limitations of the equipment.
Except for people with super magical perfect vision, the only way to do this calibration is with a test generator and a colorimeter. There are many different kinds of colorimeters ranging from the $200 version that sticks to a computer monitor all the way up to $20,000+ models used in manufacturing and production. A colorimeter measures the color temperature of light and gives a coordinate readout on either an integrated display or via software on a computer. Remember the 1931 CIE chart I recommended looking at? You’ll notice there are grid lines and X, Y axis. The color temperature 6500K relates to a coordinate of .313X, .329Y. Using the colorimeter the temperature of white can be measured and the display adjusted for proper temperature.
At CTS Audio I use what is called a non-contact colorimeter. This means I don’t have to physically attach it to the screen in order to measure the color temperature. There is a huge advantage to that type of colorimeter especially when working on projection systems. Imagine the difficulties in getting a sensor all the way up to the screen in a large venue with a bunch of cable trailing out of it! The test generator I use can generate a number of useful patterns and output just about any video format from composite analog video all the way to HD-SDI. In future blogs I’ll outline the steps for calibrating a display, different types of transmission systems for getting your video signal from point A to point B, considerations for display resolutions, and other topics related to video. For now it is good to lay the groundwork for what we’re trying to achieve. There really is no personal taste involved in calibration. It is based on the standard most applicable to the application. Making the displays behave themselves and adhere to that standard will then take skill, knowledge, and specialized equipment. In the world of cables and distribution, the adage holds “What goes in one end better come out the other just the same”. In the world of displays it should be “What you see on one should be seen on all”.

